Comments on: Learn piano before learning violin?

By: conchobor2

conchobor2 — Wed, 05 May 2010 02:17:59 +0000

Although being proficient in another insrument would’ve helped, it is NOT needed!

Heck, being profiecient in the violin may help youlearn OTHER instruments (especially stringed instruments).

I can’t say there is any clear advantage in the piano specifically for violin.
References :

By: scotgirl60

scotgirl60 — Wed, 05 May 2010 02:06:59 +0000

No that’s not true. What a bunch of rubbish.

I am a musician and I work with at least four professional violinists who can’t play one note on the piano –but they are fabulous violinists, playing with orchestras and symphonies, so find a different teacher and go from there.
References :

By: emily

emily — Wed, 05 May 2010 01:43:59 +0000

No, not at all true. Since you already did a little piano, that should help you learn the violin, but there’s really no point in spending time learning and practicing your second-choice instrument, especially since I’m guessing you’re an adult and don’t have a whole lot of spare time to practice.
The Suzuki method is a great way to start out, you should probably be able to find a certified Suzuki teacher in you area.
Good luck!
References :

By: ericabishop691

ericabishop691 — Wed, 05 May 2010 01:26:59 +0000

funny. i learned to play the violin a little, gaver it up and always watned to learn to play the piano. i think since u can read music and already have knowlege of how to play a musical instrument, u can easily pick up ( no pun intended) the vilin. Good luck to u, and i wish i neverstopped learning how to play. Another thing, do not let the fact that otrhers are better than u,make u quit like I did. Leila was the teacher's pet and she was GOOD. she began playing since she wasd 3, and she was 12 when I began to learn, and because I was not nearly as good as she was, I quit. I was only 10, and i felt inferior to her. I never did pick it back up, and I am now almost 40.
References :

By: TR

TR — Wed, 05 May 2010 01:06:59 +0000

It is absolutely false that you must become proficient on piano before you learn anything else. What does this doofus think people did BEFORE the piano was invented–pat their stomachs?

Now, the piano is an excellent tool for the musician; excellent as an accompaniment for a soloist and one of many alternatives for working out harmonies when composing or arranging. But most musicians start on their primary instrument and don’t take up piano ’til later–and then they learn it just enough to pass the dreaded "piano proficiency exam" that all music majors must pass.

My own son started on piano, gave it up, switched to drums (I always knew he’d be a drummer–born tap-happy). And now he’s playing percussion in high school band, drums in one band, and keys in another. Didn’t seem to slow him down.
References :

By: Smirks :0}

Smirks :0} — Wed, 05 May 2010 00:48:59 +0000

Perhaps that is someones idea… not a bad idea…, but is in no way necessary for success on violin or any instrument (other than maybe singing).
****Dedication to your instrument is the key to becoming proficient.
It sounds like you are interested in violin and that is already a good start. Find a reputable teacher for lessons, they are key to helping you "translate" the music from page to instrument as a beginner. Remember to enjoy listening to violin Cd’s to hear good models, and remind you why you love the instrument, and what your goals are as a player. Practice time put in will always reward you in future tense.
Best of luck to you and your violin!
References :

By: _jordan

_jordan — Wed, 05 May 2010 00:21:59 +0000

I also play the violin in an orchestra and I don't think it matters very much. As long as you know how to read music and have some basic knowledge about music, than it doesn't really matter. It depends on you.
References :